Source: United States Senator for Connecticut – Chris Murphy
September 28, 2021
WASHINGTON—U.S. Senator Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), Chairman of the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee on Near East, South Asia, Central Asia and Counterterrorism, on Tuesday delivered remarks on the U.S. Senate floor following Defense Secretary Lloyd J. Austin III, Chairman of the Joints Chiefs of Staff General Mark A. Milley, and Commander of U.S. Central Command General Kenneth McKenzie’s testimony at the U.S. Senate Armed Services Committee hearing.
On the failures of the Trump administration: “We heard also about the impossible position that President Biden inherited, that there was a commitment made to withdraw American troops by President Trump but no plan with which to do it safely. We heard about how the Doha Agreement decreased the readiness of the Afghan forces and how it weakened their position internally… We heard about the fact that had we chosen to stay, we would have had to surge troops. [We heard] that the Taliban, having gotten to the precipice of capitals, would have engaged in urban warfare that would have required the United States to increase our troops there.”
On the need for Congress to assess the limits of our military power overseas, Murphy said: “[M]y hope, Mr. President, is that moving forward, this Congress and this Senate is going to engage in real oversight. There’s no doubt the evacuation could have been done better. There’s no doubt that in a mission this complicated, the Biden team would have done things differently. But the real question is, why did we stay in Afghanistan for 10 years too long? … It’s time that we have a deep inquiry in this Senate about the limits of American military power overseas and how badly misresourced we are when we would spend 10 to 20 times as much money on military power as we do on other means of projecting American power.”
On the opportunity to focus on winnable fights with newly freed up resources and personnel, Murphy said: “[W]hen the entirety of the U.S. defense and foreign policy infrastructure is so trained on unwinnable contests in far-off places like Afghanistan, it doesn’t allow us the capacity and the creativity to be able to design new systems and new structures with which to protect the country.”
Murphy responded to generals’ previous recommendation that the U.S. stay in Afghanistan: “[F]or 20 years in Afghanistan, our generals recommended staying. In the face of mounting evidence year after year that it was going to be impossible to be able to stand up an Afghan military that can protect the country and an Afghan government that could govern the country, our generals recommended staying year after year after year, month after month after month…And to simply believe that because the generals said ‘stay another year’ or ‘stay another five years,’ this Commander in Chief should have listened despite the fact that it had been proven that the mission we were given in that country was impossible is to compound a mistake, an unnecessary mistake that the United States engaged in for far, far too long.”
Click here to watch his floor speech in full.
A full transcript of his remarks can be found below:
“Thank you, Mr. President. I come to the floor to offer some brief remarks today in the wake of the Armed Services Committee hearing today on the evacuation of the Afghanistan and the end to U.S. troop presence there. I watched it with some interest. I watched it knowing that three out of four Americans support President Biden’s decision to bring U.S. troops home from Afghanistan.
“We learned some new things today in the hearing, others were confirmed. First, we learned once again of the extraordinary bravery and capability of our diplomats and our soldiers who worked under incredibly difficult conditions for a period of weeks to airlift almost 130,000 individuals out of Afghanistan. That is absolutely remarkable, especially given as we heard today in testimony that the goal at the outset in the best case scenario, was to get 60 to 70 to 80,000 people out. In the end, the United States of America, our military, and our diplomats got 130,000 people out.
“We heard also about the impossible position that President Biden inherited, that there was a commitment made to withdraw American troops by President Trump, but no plan with which to do it safely. We heard about how the Doha Agreement decreased the readiness of the Afghan forces, how it weakened their position internally. We heard about the choice that faced President Biden when he came into office. We heard about the fact that had we chosen to stay, we would have had to surge troops. [We heard] that the Taliban having gotten to the precipice of provincial capitals, would have engaged in a level of urban warfare that would have required the United States to increase our troop presence there in order to be able to stand up an effective resistance to the Taliban.
“To the extent that the Republicans view this is a political gain and they were looking for points to be scored today, I guess the one point they feel they scored was an admission by the generals that testified that some of them had recommended stay in Afghanistan. Now, I have tremendous respect for our generals, I think they get it right more than they get it wrong. They provide very able advice to the Commander in Chief.
“But for 20 years in Afghanistan, our generals recommended staying. In the face of mounting evidence year after year that it was going to be impossible to be able to stand up an Afghan military that can protect the country and an Afghan government that could govern the country, our generals recommending staying year after year after year, month after month after month despite the fact that many analysts told us that as soon as we left the Taliban would take over the Afghan government and the military would fall.
“They did it because our military is bred to believe that anything is possible. It speaks in some part to the best American military ethos, the idea that there is no obstacle that cannot be surmounted that cannot be climbed by U.S. Armed Forces. But the task they were given by president after president was one that could not be carried out. And to simply believe that because the general said ‘stay another year or stay another five years,’ this Commander in Chief should have listened despite the fact that it had been proven that the mission we were given in that country was impossible is to compound a mistake, an unnecessary mistake that the United States engaged in for far, far too long.
“And so my hope, Mr. President, is that moving forward, this Congress and this Senate is going to engage in real oversight. There’s no doubt the evacuation could have been done better. There’s no doubt that in a mission this complicated, the Biden team would have done things differently. But the real question is, why did we stay in Afghanistan for 10 years too long? Why did we keep believing that we could train up a military that would be capable of defending the country?
“It’s time that we have a deep inquiry in this Senate about the limits of American military power overseas and how badly misresourced we are when we would spend 10 to 20 times as much money on military power as we do on other means of projecting American power. And it’s also important for us to understand the costs of getting bogged down in places like Afghanistan and Iraq.
“It’s not a coincidence that shortly after withdrawing from Afghanistan, we were able to announce this new partnership with Australia and Britain to better protect our mutual interests in the Pacific Theater. It’s because when the entirety of the U.S. defense and foreign policy infrastructure is so trained on unwinnable contests in far-off places like Afghanistan, it doesn’t allow us the capacity and the creativity to be able to design new systems and new structures with which to protect the country. China celebrated every single year that we remained bogged down in Afghanistan, Russia celebrated every single year that we doubled down on that mistake.
“Now, we have the ability to turn our attention to fights that truly matter. We learned some things in the Armed Services Committee today. I think what we learned confirmed that the decision that President Biden made to pull our troops out was the right one. It’s a decision supported by the American people because it allows this country finally to focus on fights that are winnable in reality, not just on paper.”
###